Tips for Appealing Insurance Denials (Attorney-Crafted Guide to Winning Your Health Claim Appeal)

When a health insurance claim is denied, most people feel confused, overwhelmed, and defeated. And that’s exactly what insurers hope for — because less than 1% of denied claims are ever appealed, even though 40–60% of appeals succeed.

As a lawyer who has helped countless families overturn wrongful denials, I’ve seen how small mistakes in the appeal process can cost patients thousands of dollars… and how the right strategy can completely turn a case around.

This guide will teach you the exact steps, tips, and insider strategies insurance companies don’t explain — practical, legally informed advice to help you submit a stronger appeal and dramatically increase your chances of approval.

1. Start by Understanding Why Your Claim Was Denied

Before you can win an appeal, you must diagnose the denial. Insurance companies typically rely on these categories:

Common Denial Reasons

• “Not medically necessary”

• “Out-of-network provider”

• “Policy exclusion”

• “Experimental / investigational”

• Coding errors (CO-167, CO-50, CO-18, PR-1, etc.)

• Missing documentation

• Lack of referral or preauthorization

Tip: Insurers often use vague, generic phrases. Don’t accept them at face value. Look for:

• CPT/ICD-10 codes referenced

• Policy language cited

• Any evidence they claim is missing

If anything is unclear, request a clarification in writing. Under federal law (ERISA), you are entitled to an explanation.

2. Gather Every Piece of Evidence You Need (Before You Appeal)

Your appeal must include everything you want the insurer to consider.

Strong Evidence to Include

• Medical records (complete chart notes, test results, imaging)

• Doctor’s letter of medical necessity (ask for specifics, not generic statements)

• Timeline of symptoms, treatments, and failed alternatives

• Itemized bill + corrected claim (if codes are wrong)

• Proof of payment or balance bills

• Proof the service is covered under your plan

• For out-of-network denials: evidence no in-network provider could perform the service

Pro tip from an attorney: A doctor’s letter is strongest when paired with a professionally structured appeal letter. Your appeal template guides your doctor on exactly what insurers look for — so their support letter hits all the required medical points.

3. Request Your Plan Documents (Insiders Never Skip This Step)

Most people have never seen their actual policy. Insurers count on this.

Request:

• Full plan document / certificate of coverage

• Summary plan description (SPD)

• Internal guidelines used for your claim

• Any clinical criteria or medical policies they applied

Under ERISA (for employer-provided plans), they must provide this.

Why this matters:

Your best appeal arguments come from the insurer’s own rules:

• “Your policy states X, and my treatment meets X.”

• “Your criteria require Y, and I provided Y.”

Turning their rules into your evidence is one of the most powerful appeal strategies.

4. Fix Coding, Billing, and Administrative Errors First

Up to 20–30% of denials are not medical — they are clerical.

Examples:

• CPT/ICD mismatch (diagnosis doesn’t support procedure)

• Unbundled codes

• Place-of-service errors

• Missing modifiers

• Wrong insurance ID or birthdate

• Deductible or PR-1 miscalculations

If your denial is based on a code (CO-167, CO-18, CO-50, PR-1), call the provider’s billing office and ask for a corrected claim. Many denials vanish once codes match policy requirements.

5. Write a Strong, Structured Appeal Letter

This is where most DIY appeals fail. Insurers prefer long rants and emotional pleas — because they’re easy to deny.

A powerful appeal letter includes:

✔ A clear introduction

• State you are appealing

• List the date of service, CPT code, and denial reason

• Cite the claim number

✔ A legal & medical argument section

Use:

• Your policy language

• Medical records

• Industry guidelines

• Peer-reviewed literature (if needed)

• Insurance company’s own rules

✔ A timeline of events

Explain the progression of illness or injury, failed conservative treatments, and why the service was necessary.

✔ A conclusion demanding approval

Request overturning the denial and reimbursement within a reasonable timeframe.

Attorney tip: Use the phrase “Please include this letter and all attachments in the administrative record.” This signals you understand your rights — and insurers take those appeals more seriously. For more legal tips on how to win your appeal, get my FREE Appeal Guide.

6. Strengthen Your Appeal With a Doctor’s Support Letter

A doctor’s letter should not say simply, “The treatment is necessary.”

It should:

• Address the insurer’s exact denial reason

• Reference test results, imaging, or lab markers

• Explain failed alternatives

• Describe consequences of delaying treatment

• Cite recognized medical guidelines

Insurers give enormous weight to physician support.

7. Meet All Deadlines — One Missed Deadline Can Kill Your Appeal

Every denial letter includes:

• Appeal deadline (often 180 days, sometimes 60)

• Instructions on where to send your appeal

• Whether email, fax, or portal submissions are allowed

If you miss the deadline, insurers can legally refuse to review your appeal.

Attorney Tip: Send your appeal by two methods (e.g., upload + certified mail or fax). Keep all confirmation pages. For more legal tips on how to win your appeal, get my FREE Appeal Guide.

8. Use the Insurer’s Internal Appeals Against Them

Most plans require:

• 1st-level appeal

• 2nd-level appeal

• External review (for many plans)

Why this matters:

External reviewers are independent physicians — and they overturn denials regularly when insurers get the medicine wrong.

Your goal is to build a record strong enough that the external reviewer cannot ignore it.

9. Look for Patterns in the Insurer’s Behavior (This Is an Attorney Secret)

Many denials follow predictable patterns. Look for:

• Copy-and-paste denial language

• Criteria not actually applied to your case

• Failure to review records you sent

• Use of outdated coverage policies

• Contradictions in their reasoning

Pointing out these patterns increases your odds significantly and signals you are prepared to escalate if needed.

10. When to Escalate Beyond an Appeal

Some denials are too complex, medically advanced, or legally sensitive to handle alone.

Seek help when:

• Your denial involves policy exclusions

• You were accused of misrepresentation

• There is large dollar value at stake

• Your provider’s coding office cannot fix repeated denials

• A surgical or hospital claim was denied as “not medically necessary”

• Insurer delays or ignores your appeal for months

A lawyer can force proper review, submit legal arguments, and protect you if the claim becomes litigation.

11. The Most Common Mistakes That Cause Appeals to Fail

If you avoid these, your chances of success increase dramatically:

❌ Missing documentation

❌ Emotional arguments instead of factual ones

❌ Not citing policy language

❌ Allowing the provider to handle everything (they don’t have skin in the game)

❌ Not requesting internal guidelines

❌ Not correcting coding errors first

❌ Late submissions

Most people don’t lose because they’re wrong — they lose because they don’t know the rules.

12. Sample Appeal Argument Structure You Can Use

Here is a simple but powerful structure:

1. Identify the denial reason

“My claim was denied for CO-50 — lack of medical necessity.”

2. Cite the insurer’s own rules

“Your Medical Policy XYZ requires (1) diagnosis A, (2) symptom B, and (3) documentation of failed conservative treatment. My records include all three.”

3. Point out factual errors

“Your denial states no MRI was provided, but pages 12–15 of the enclosed record include the MRI findings.”

4. Demonstrate medical necessity

Provide evidence from your doctor.

5. Demand reconsideration

Short, direct, professional.

This structure keeps your argument organized and persuasive.

13. Final Tip: Don’t Give Up After One Denial

Insurers often deny valid claims on the first attempt — sometimes automatically. Many approvals happen only after the second-level appeal or external review.

Every round of appeal builds pressure on the insurer and increases your chances of winning.

Need a professionally written appeal letter?
Avoid mistakes that risk your claim. My attorney-drafted templates give you winning arguments, checklists, and evidence guides for every major denial reason.
👉 Get your appeal template instantly at AppealTemplates.com